New York Slip and Fall
Settlement Calculator

New York applies pure comparative fault — the victim recovers even if primarily at fault, with proportional reduction. New York City has extensive regulations on sidewalk maintenance — liability often falls on adjacent property owners for city sidewalk defects.

Government entities (city, state, MTA) require formal Notice of Claim within 90 days of the accident — missing this administrative deadline bars the lawsuit.

Plaintiff-favorable: New York's pure comparative fault rule means you can recover even if you were 70% or 80% at fault for the fall — your damages are simply reduced by your percentage. This is the most plaintiff-friendly standard and makes slip and fall cases more viable even where the victim was somewhat careless.

Statute of limitations: 3 years. Governing statute: NY CPLR § 1411.

Pure comparative fault. New York has detailed notice requirements — municipalities have short notice windows.

New York's courts are plaintiff-favorable, particularly in New York City, Brooklyn, Queens, and the Bronx.

Slip and fall settlement values in New York are driven by: (1) Injury severity — minor sprains and bruises: $10,000–$30,000; fractures requiring surgery: $50,000–$150,000; back/spine injuries or TBI: $100,000–$500,000+. (2) Liability strength — how obvious the hazard was, how long it existed, whether there were warning signs, and how clearly the owner was on notice.

(3) Your fault percentage — in New York, even significant victim fault doesn't bar recovery — it only reduces damages proportionally.

(4) Documentation — cases with surveillance video, incident reports, prior complaints, and maintenance logs settle for significantly higher amounts than cases relying on victim testimony alone. (5) Insurance limits — most commercial premises have $1M+ general liability coverage; homeowner policies have $100K–$300K.

Cases against self-insured large retailers (Walmart, Target, Home Depot) can access deeper resources but face experienced national defense teams.

The hardest element in most New York slip and fall cases is proving the property owner knew (or should have known) about the hazard. Evidence that establishes notice includes: (1) Prior complaints — complaints to staff, incident reports from prior falls on the same hazard; (2) Maintenance logs — gaps in inspection records show the owner failed to check the area in a reasonable time; (3) Duration of the hazard — a spill that existed for 45 minutes is easier to prove than one from 5 minutes ago; (4) Surveillance video — request preservation immediately; commercial properties routinely overwrite footage in 24–72 hours; (5) Employee statements — staff who knew about the hazard before the fall.

In New York, the 'constructive notice' standard requires showing the condition existed long enough that a reasonable inspection would have discovered it. The longer the hazard existed, the stronger the argument that the owner 'should have known.' Gathering this evidence quickly — before it's overwritten or destroyed — is essential.